Showalter also identifies the 'Crazy Jane' - a poor servant girl abandoned by her lover - who originated with Gothic novelist Matthew Lewis and 'Lucy' - a crazed, violent figure who originated in Sir Walter Scott's The Bride of Lammermoor. Doctors diagnosed & labelled certain types of madwomen according to types they found in literature - the most obvious being Shakespeare's Ophelia, who came to represent a Romantic fantasy of the young, beautiful, lovestruck, suicidal madwoman. One of the most striking things about this book was Showalter's illustration of the relationship between medicine & art.

I ended up with 15 new additions to my TBR list from the novels Showalter references alone! (Part of the sudden rush to read West and Woolf also, it coincided nicely with my new desire to learn more about WW1, since so much of it focused on WW1-era mental health issues.) A good example of popular scholarship & I liked how it presents debates rather than closing them off. I thought it was great, very interesting, if dated (its from 1985, I think). At just 250 pages, The Female Malady is by no means a complete history, but proves to be a useful volume on its own, especially for those considering cultural and literary implications of insanity beyond the straight-forward studies of psychology or psychoanalytic theory. Showalter skillfully blends historical observation and study with careful literary analysis to give her reader and understanding of the material from several angles and increase their awareness of the historical implications of insanity not just for the evolution of women, but for the sciences and literary fields alike. However, the text does not end there, and moves on to discuss everything from evolving practices in institutions, the feminization of mental disease, the presence and treatment of male patients, psychoanalysis, and the feminist therapy movement. The majority of the text focuses on the plight of the Victorian woman, and how doctors and the medical profession responded to what they perceived as the nervous energy attached to the rising discontent of women as a gendered class. Drawing on a cultural sangria of material, The Female Malady traces the systematic (and often blundering) treatment of mental disease, focusing on how women influenced the establishment as not only patients, but commentators in the form of employees and writers, activists and advocates.

Showalter's research is thorough, and her presentation of information shows a care and attentiveness to her material that increases the confidence of the reader. Elaine Showlater's The Female Malady: Women, Madness and English Culture, 1830-1980 is a brilliant discussion of the perception and treatment of mental illness, focusing on the female perspective.

Showalter the female malady